• Home
  • Blog
  • Bad Diet Advice and What You Should Do Instead
Weight Coaching | March 14, 2017  | by  Shari Broder | 5 COMMENT
Bad Diet Advice | Weight Loss for Foodies

Despite about 1/3 of Americans being overweight, there’s no shortage of diet advice available, especially on the Internet. Some of it is completely outrageous. Some of it is just plain bad.

On Pinterest, I saw a “lose 30 pounds in one month” diet, which I’m pretty sure must involve something like amputating a limb. If people didn’t still fall for that stuff, it wouldn’t be out there.

I’m a questioner with no tendency to believe anything I read. Others tend to trust what they see in print. Wherever you fall along that spectrum, here is a list of diet advice that you should definitely NOT take!

1. Eat before you go to a party to curb your appetite. Seriously? Assuming the party is going to have tantalizing foods, this is a terrible idea. Most people are overweight because they eat too much. Walking into a party with lots of yummy things is no less tempting because you’ve already eaten and makes it more likely that you’ll end up overeating.

INSTEAD: Go to a party with a good appetite, but not so hungry that you aren’t discerning about what you eat. Find what looks good, and take a reasonable amount of those foods and balance unhealthy choices with healthier ones. Read more about how to enjoy parties without gaining weight here

2. Eat breakfast every day. A good breakfast is wonderful, if you’re hungry. Our bodies have this amazing ability to tell us when to eat and when to stop, but only if we listen. We only need food when we are hungry, however, so if you aren’t hungry at breakfast time and you eat anyway, your body will store those calories as fat.

INSTEAD: Eat breakfast if and when you’re hungry in the morning. If you aren’t hungry, don’t eat until you are. If you think you’ll become hungry at a time when you won’t have access to a meal, bring a healthy snack, like nuts or cheese.

3. You can eat as much as you want of low calorie foods and vegetables. Someone once told me that we burn more calories eating celery than the celery has so it is okay to eat as much as you want. So how much celery do you actually want to eat? I can tell you from experience that I gained a lot of weight eating too much healthy food! It is never a good idea to eat an unlimited amount of anything. You should always respect your body’s signals and stop eating before your stomach is distended by food.

INSTEAD: Your body will tell you how much food it needs. Stop eating before you feel full. Eat a variety of foods.

4. You’ll lose weight and be healthier if you don’t eat gluten. The Celiac Center at Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital in Boston has said that unless you are one of a very small percentage of the population who is sensitive to gluten, you will derive no benefit from giving it up, and you may actually end up consuming a less healthy diet. There is no medical evidence that omitting gluten from your diet will help you lose weight. Because whole grains are a major source of fiber, some people become constipated upon giving up gluten. Others develop dietary deficiencies because so many gluten-free foods are heavily processed and comprised of things with low or no nutritional value, like xanthan gum, tapioca and white rice flour.

INSTEAD: Seek the advice of your doctor before deciding to omit nutritious whole grains like wheat, rye and oats from your diet.

5. Eating fat makes you fat. Fifty years ago, the sugar industry funded research and bribed scientists to downplay the risks of sugar and highlight the hazards of eating fat. This actually contributed to obesity and heart disease. When people eat less fat, they tend to get hungry sooner and eat more sugar and simple starches to compensate, which actually increases LDL cholesterol, and the risk of heart disease and diabetes.

INSTEAD: Eat a diet with about 1/3 of your calories from good quality fat, while eating a very small amount of refined carbohydrates and sugar. Foods like nuts, seeds, avocados, extra virgin olive oil and fish with omega-3 fats actually keep you full longer and reduce your risk of heart attack.

In conclusion, it is a good idea to eat a variety of foods when your body is hungry and to stop before you have eaten too much and feel full. People who do this generally don’t have to worry about their weight or all of the food rules floating around the Internet.

About the author 

Shari Broder

My mission is to help foodies ditch dieting and lose the weight for good. Discover what is really causing your weight issues (it isn't that you love food!), and learn how to stop obsessing about food and make peace with food and eating. Get off the diet hamster wheel once and for all and learn to eat consciously, stop emotional eating and enjoy the foods you love while permanently losing your desire to overeat.

  1. Good post! When it comes to weight loss, the craziness out there is amazing and ever changing. Ten years ago canola oil was the big thing. The last few years I’ve read articles saying no, cut the canola oil and use olive oil. Lately I’ve seen that olive oil should never be heated, only served at room temp, and so we should be using the healthier coconut oil. Every time someone does a “study” the rules change. Fortunately, good common sense doesn’t go out of style.

  2. So true! Who would have thought people would put butter in their coffee to lose weight? Hard to keep up with all of it! Thanks for your comments.

  3. I agree with Lisa’s comment! It is crazy how people will simply follow the newest health trend without doing any research or finding out if it is actually beneficial or not.

Comments are closed.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Meet Shari

I am passionate about helping women lose weight without dieting by teaching them how to trust their inner wisdom and make peace with food and eating.  I love teaching women how to get off the diet hamster wheel by learning how to eat consciously, stop emotional eating and enjoy foods they love while losing their desire to overeat along with their excess weight.